Judge: Maciej BIAŁEK

ACRO Single Sequence FPS Analysis for Judge 8: Maciej BIAŁEK - POL

Ranking Index = 7,89

The 20th FAI WGAC 2017, Toruń, POLAND, July 27 - August 5

Judges nation	High value
Panel / neutral	Low value

Unlimited - Glider, Programme 1: Free Known

Raw and normalised / FPS revised marks and scores

FP Rank before penalties		Fig-1	Fig-2	Fig-3	Fig-4	Fig-5	Fig-6	Fig-7	Fig-8	Fig-9	Fig-10	Posi	No	RI / FP	J-rank	Diff
1	Ferenc TÓTH - HUN	8,0	8,0	8,5	8,0	8,0	9,0	9,0	9,0	8,5	8,5	8,5	0	Hi 2023,5	1
	Swift S-1 HA-7022	8,13	7,65	8,48	7,35	7,60	8,66	8,68	9,01	8,90	8,75	8,23		1194,9
2	Luca BERTOSSIO - ITA	8,0	8,5	8,5	8,0	8,0	8,0	7,0	7,0	7,0	8,0	7,5	0	1823,4	2
	Swift S-1 D6018	7,60	8,16	8,29	7,35	7,65	7,86	7,24	6,77	6,26	8,13	7,17		1892,0
3	Eric LENTZ-GAUTHIER - USA	8,0	8,0	8,5	8,0	7,5	8,0	7,0	7,0	6,5	7,0	8,0	0	1769,7	7	-4
	Swift S-1 OE-5607	7,92	7,86	8,16	7,92	6,91	7,60	6,77	6,66	6,68	6,57	7,70		1825,9
4	János SONKOLY - HUN	8,5	8,0	6,5	7,0	7,5	9,0	7,0	8,0	6,0	7,5	8,5	0	1767,4	8	-4
	Swift S-1 HA-7022	8,90	7,65	6,20	6,46	7,11	8,66	6,61	7,86	6,13	7,09	8,23		1772,6
5	Vladimir ILINSKIY - RUS	8,0	7,5	7,0	9,0	7,5	7,5	8,0	6,5	6,0	7,5	7,5	0	1735,3	10	-5
	Swift S-1 RA0421	7,86	7,11	6,61	8,66	7,15	7,34	8,13	6,01	6,13	7,09	7,17		1767,9
6	János SZILÁGYI - HUN	8,0	6,5	7,5	7,5	8,0	9,0	8,0	7,5	6,5	8,0	8,5	0	1809,6	4	+2
	Swift S-1 HA-7022	8,13	6,17	7,34	6,91	7,60	8,66	7,64	7,29	6,68	7,92	8,23		1737,3
7	Georgij KAMINSKIY - RUS	8,0	7,0	8,0	9,0	8,0	7,5	8,0	6,5	7,0	7,5	9,0	0	1821,0	3	+4
	Swift S-1 RA0421	7,86	6,61	7,64	8,66	7,65	7,34	8,13	6,01	7,24	7,09	8,76		1812,2
8	Eugen SCHAAL - GER	7,0	7,5	6,0	Lo 4,0	7,5	7,0	7,5	7,0	7,0	6,5	6,5	1	1572,1	15	-7
	Swift S-1 D-8139	6,26	7,34	5,67	7,17	6,91	6,71	7,12	7,19	7,24	5,79	6,11		1821,9
9	Marvin WOLTERING - GER	7,5	7,5	6,0	7,0	8,5	8,0	8,0	8,5	7,5	7,5	8,0	0	1782,4	6	+3
	MDM-1 Fox D1187	7,35	7,34	5,67	6,61	7,80	7,86	7,64	8,29	7,79	7,09	7,70		1647,5
10	Gisbert LEIMKUHLER - GER	7,5	7,0	8,0	8,0	7,5	7,0	7,0	7,0	8,0	Hi 7,5	8,5	1	1763,7	9	+1
	Swift S-1 D3168	7,35	6,61	7,92	7,35	7,29	6,66	6,77	7,24	7,92	5,43	8,23		1784,5
11	Moritz KIRCHBERG - GER	8,5	7,5	4,0	6,0	9,0	8,5	8,5	8,5	6,5	6,0	8,5	0	1706,1	12	-1
	Swift S-1 D3735	8,29	7,34	3,69	6,13	8,25	8,44	8,16	8,75	5,79	5,62	8,23		1733,7
12	Jan MAKULA - POL	8,0	9,0	9,0	5,5	6,0	6,0	7,5	7,0	7,0	7,5	8,0	0	1645,4	14	-2
	Swift S-1 SP-3529	7,60	8,68	8,66	5,58	5,62	5,67	6,91	6,57	6,71	7,09	7,70		1707,6
13	Miloš RAMERT - CZE	8,0	7,0	9,0	6,5	6,0	7,0	8,5	Hi 8,0	7,5	7,5	7,0	1	1714,2	11	+2
	MDM-1 Fox OK-7801	8,13	6,61	8,66	6,68	5,62	6,66	7,80	6,45	7,09	7,11	6,64		1646,2
14	Stanisław MAKULA - POL	8,5	8,5	8,0	7,0	6,5	5,0	8,5	7,5	8,5	Hi 8,5	9,0	1	1800,2	5	+9
	Swift S-1 SP-3529	8,10	8,16	7,92	7,24	6,20	4,68	7,80	7,35	8,44	5,63	8,76		1696,0
15	Michael SPITZER - GER	7,0	6,5	6,0	7,5	8,0	7,5	8,0	9,0	7,0	7,0	7,5	0	1676,9	13	+2
	MDM-1 Fox D1187	6,57	6,20	5,67	7,11	7,35	7,29	7,64	8,66	7,24	6,26	7,17		1743,2
16	Wolfgang SCHIECK - GER	8,5	7,5	7,0	7,0	7,0	7,5	8,0	6,5	6,5	6,5	7,5	0	1488,3	16
	Swift S-1 D3169	8,44	7,34	6,66	6,46	6,26	7,12	7,92	6,68	5,79	6,12	7,17		1677,6
17	Bernhard BEHR - AUT	8,0	7,0	9,0	5,0	6,5	5,0	8,0	6,5	6,5	3,5	6,5	0	Lo 1421,6	18	-1
	Swift S-1 OE-5554	7,86	6,61	8,66	4,48	6,17	5,02	7,35	5,79	5,42	3,15	6,11		1656,6
18	Takashi SAKAI - JPN	8,0	6,0	6,5	6,0	6,5	6,0	6,5	6,0	7,0	6,5	7,5	0	1486,3	17	+1
	Swift S-1 SP-3529	7,86	6,13	6,17	5,62	6,01	4,59	6,82	5,57	6,61	5,79	7,17		1547,0
19	Siegfried MAYR - AUT	6,5	4,0	6,0	6,5	7,0	4,0	6,5	6,0	6,5	7,0	7,0	0	1373,0	19
	Swift S-1 OE-5554	5,42	3,69	5,62	6,09	7,19	3,78	5,79	6,13	6,20	6,71	6,64		1484,3
20	Gabriel STANGL - AUT	8,0	8,0	6,0	8,0	HZ	7,0	7,0	7,0	Lo 0,0	7,0	7,5	1	1315,9	21	-1
	Swift S-1 OE-5554	7,92	7,65	6,13	7,35	HZ	7,19	6,61	6,61	3,85	6,71	7,17		1371,6
21	Eberhard HOLL - GER	8,0	8,0	7,5	7,0	7,0	6,0	HZ	HZ	7,5	6,5	8,0	0	1364,0	20	+1
	Swift S-1 D9630	7,86	7,64	7,56	6,77	6,66	6,13	HZ	HZ	7,09	6,12	7,70		1396,8
22	Tobias HACKEL - GER	8,0	7,5	7,0	6,0	7,5	5,5	7,5	HZ	HZ	HZ	8,5	0	1278,7	22
	Swift S-1 D9680	7,60	7,34	6,66	5,57	7,09	5,58	7,56	HZ	HZ	HZ	8,23		1362,0
23	Daniel SERRES - FRA	8,0	8,5	7,0	7,0	HZ	HZ	7,0	HZ	8,0	7,5	8,0	0	1196,2	23
	Swift S-1 F-CHBA	7,92	8,16	6,57	6,66	HZ	HZ	7,24	HZ	7,92	7,29	7,70		1276,5
		0	0	0	1	0	0	0	1	1	2	0	5	2		50

FPS revised marks

Distribution of raw marks

Mark to CHZ	-
PZ to CHZ	-
AV to CHZ	-
AV to Mark	-
PZ to Mark	-
HZ to Mark	-
Lo to Mark	2
Hi to Mark	3
The 60% rule	-
This judge's raw marks
Whole panel after FPS

Review of anomalies

Mark anomalies		Judge 1	Judge 2	Judge 3	Judge 4	Judge 5	Judge 6	Judge 7	Judge 8	Ch.Judge
Eugen SCHAAL - GER	Fig-4	6,0	8,0	7,5	7,0	7,5	7,0	7,0	Lo 4,0	OK
Swift S-1 D-8139		6,56	7,85	7,26	7,36	8,08	6,69	6,42	7,17
Gabriel STANGL - AUT	Fig-9	5,0	4,0	2,0	2,0	Hi 6,0	Lo 0,0	Hi 7,5	Lo 0,0	OK
Swift S-1 OE-5554		5,05	3,44	2,87	4,05	3,85	3,85	3,85	3,85
Gisbert LEIMKUHLER - GER	Fig-10	Lo 0,0	5,0	7,0	5,0	5,0	4,5	6,5	Hi 7,5	OK
Swift S-1 D3168		5,43	5,60	6,51	5,49	5,31	3,97	5,70	5,43
Miloš RAMERT - CZE	Fig-8	5,0	7,0	6,0	7,0	6,0	6,5	7,0	Hi 8,0	OK
MDM-1 Fox OK-7801		5,88	6,89	5,73	7,00	6,14	6,57	6,94	6,45
Stanisław MAKULA - POL	Fig-10	Lo 0,0	5,0	6,0	6,0	2,0	7,0	6,5	Hi 8,5	OK
Swift S-1 SP-3529		5,63	5,03	5,36	6,54	3,74	6,81	6,30	5,63


Score anomalies	Judge 1	Judge 2	Judge 3	Judge 4	Judge 5	Judge 6	Judge 7	Judge 8
Ferenc TÓTH - HUN	1790,6	1978,5	1799,1	1835,8	1945,5	1918,5	1768,1	Hi 2023,5
Swift S-1 HA-7022								1892,0
Bernhard BEHR - AUT	1575,4	1588,5	1523,2	1545,7	Hi 1670,2	1493,7	1478,9	Lo 1421,6
Swift S-1 OE-5554					1535,7			1547,0

Review of Judge style and RI items

Pilots not ranked correctly	Aeroplane	Judge score	Bias Hi/Lo	Panel score	Score difference	Judge rank	Panel rank	Rank diff'ce	RI value this pilot	Percent of total	RI elements ranked by decreasing size
Eugen SCHAAL - GER	Swift S-1	1578,3	-	1730,5	- 152,1	15	8	- 7	2,28	28,8%
Stanisław MAKULA - POL	Swift S-1	1781,5	-	1670,2	+ 111,3	5	14	+ 9	2,22	28,1%
Georgij KAMINSKIY - RUS	Swift S-1	1800,1	-	1736,9	+ 63,2	3	7	+ 4	0,54	6,8%
Eric LENTZ-GAUTHIER - USA	Swift S-1	1754,3	-	1812,9	- 58,6	7	3	- 4	0,48	6,1%
Vladimir ILINSKIY - RUS	Swift S-1	1723,7	-	1760,4	- 36,7	10	5	- 5	0,39	4,9%
János SONKOLY - HUN	Swift S-1	1752,3	-	1785,3	- 33,0	8	4	- 4	0,27	3,5%
Marvin WOLTERING - GER	MDM-1 Fox	1765,7	-	1729,7	+ 36,0	6	9	+ 3	0,23	2,9%
Bernhard BEHR - AUT	Swift S-1	1444,2	Lo	1536,1	- 91,8	18	17	- 1	0,22	2,8%
Eberhard HOLL - GER	Swift S-1	1392,8	-	1313,4	+ 79,4	20	21	+ 1	0,22	2,8%
Jan MAKULA - POL	Swift S-1	1643,6	-	1692,4	- 48,8	14	12	- 2	0,21	2,7%
János SZILÁGYI - HUN	Swift S-1	1789,9	-	1745,0	+ 45,0	4	6	+ 2	0,19	2,4%
Gabriel STANGL - AUT	Swift S-1	1350,0	-	1416,6	- 66,6	21	20	- 1	0,17	2,2%
Michael SPITZER - GER	MDM-1 Fox	1671,7	-	1635,7	+ 36,0	13	15	+ 2	0,16	2,1%
Miloš RAMERT - CZE	MDM-1 Fox	1705,0	-	1671,4	+ 33,6	11	13	+ 2	0,15	1,9%
Takashi SAKAI - JPN	Swift S-1	1501,9	-	1535,2	- 33,3	17	18	+ 1	0,08	1,0%
Gisbert LEIMKUHLER - GER	Swift S-1	1749,1	-	1725,0	+ 24,1	9	10	+ 1	0,05	0,7%
Moritz KIRCHBERG - GER	Swift S-1	1697,7	-	1711,5	- 13,7	12	11	- 1	0,03	0,4%

Pilots ranked correctly		Judge score		Panel score	Score difference	Judge rank	Panel rank
Ferenc TÓTH - HUN	Swift S-1	1980,5		1865,2	+ 115,3	1	1
Luca BERTOSSIO - ITA	Swift S-1	1802,2		1830,6	- 28,3	2	2
Wolfgang SCHIECK - GER	Swift S-1	1503,6		1605,9	- 102,2	16	16
Siegfried MAYR - AUT	Swift S-1	1400,9		1459,0	- 58,1	19	19
Tobias HACKEL - GER	Swift S-1	1316,9		1207,3	+ 109,6	22	22
Daniel SERRES - FRA	Swift S-1	1243,3		1173,5	+ 69,9	23	23

Total RI contribution per nation

Judge:	max nation bias = 2,00	min = -1,64	o/all average = -0,02
Panel:	= 10,95	min = -3,88

Ranking Index totals per nation
using the +/- rank differences to show
national bias from the most to the
least favoured teams of Pilots

The number of Pilots in each nation
is shown with the nationality

Calculations by: FairPlay (non-scoring CJ + CHZ Summary)
Aerobatic Contest Results Organiser, ACRO Version 4.2 Build: 23-07-17