Judge: Maciej BIAŁEK

ACRO Sequence FPS Analysis for Judge 2: Maciej BIAŁEK - POL

Ranking Index = 30,55

WGAC 2023, Toruń, Poland, July 26 to August 6

Pilot NAT = Judge NAT

FPS High value

FPS Low value

Unlimited - Glider, Programme 2: 1st Unknown Compulsory

HZ Anomalies

Set to Panel Avg

Raw and normalised / FPS revised Marks and Scores

FP Rank before penalties		Fig-1	Fig-2	Fig-3	Fig-4	Fig-5	Fig-6	Fig-7	Fig-8	Posi	No	Raw/FPS	J-rank	Diff
1	Maciej POSPIESZYŃSKI - POL	8,0	8,0	7,5	8,5	8,0	8,5	7,5	7,0	8,0	0	1821,13	1
	Swift S-1 SP-3532	8,69	8,19	7,58	8,50	7,36	8,20	7,51	6,72	8,05		1828,73
2	Michael SPITZER - GER	6,5	8,0	7,0	8,0	8,5	8,5	8,5	6,5	8,0	0	1771,79	2
	Swift S-1 D-3735	7,08	8,19	7,25	8,09	7,74	8,20	8,31	6,20	8,05		1780,59
3	Eric LENTZ-GAUTHIER - USA	6,5	7,0	6,5	7,0	6,0	7,5	8,0	6,0	7,0	0	1591,15	7	-4
	Swift S-1 HA-7022	7,08	7,39	6,92	7,25	5,84	7,54	7,91	5,68	7,21		1617,53
4	Charly LEVY LOUAPRE - FRA	6,0	6,5	4,0	7,5	6,0	7,5	6,5	6,5	7,5	0	1510,40	10	-6
	Swift S-1 HA-7022	6,54	7,00	6,67	7,67	5,84	7,54	6,71	6,20	7,63		1614,01
5	Michał KLIMASZEWSKI - POL	7,0	7,5	7,0	7,5	6,0	7,0	7,5	7,0	7,0	0	1653,73	5
	Swift S-1 SP-3532	7,62	7,79	7,25	7,67	5,84	7,21	7,51	6,72	7,21		1659,07
6	Sebastian DIRLAM - GER	7,5	8,0	6,0	9,0	4,0	6,5	7,0	6,5	6,5	0	1554,27	8	-2
	Swift S-1 D-7125	8,16	8,19	6,59	8,92	4,32	6,87	7,11	6,20	6,80		1563,43
7	Wolfgang SCHIECK - GER	6,0	7,5	7,0	7,0	7,0	8,0	7,5	HZ	7,5	1	1430,11	11	-4
	Swift S-1 D-9590	6,54	7,79	7,25	8,14	6,60	7,87	7,51	4,36	7,63		1598,76
8	Bernhard BEHR - AUT	8,0	8,0	7,5	8,5	5,0	4,5	6,0	4,0	8,5	0	1534,72	9	-1
	Swift S-1 OE-5554	8,69	8,19	7,58	8,50	5,08	5,54	6,31	3,68	8,47		1539,48
9	Siegfried MAYR - AUT	6,5	8,0	8,0	8,0	8,0	8,0	7,5	6,5	8,0	1	1752,83	3	+6
	Swift S-1 OE-5554	7,08	8,19	7,91	8,09	7,36	7,87	CHZ	6,20	8,05		1559,93
10	Robin KEMTER - GER	6,0	7,5	7,0	8,5	0,0	7,0	7,5	7,0	9,0	0	1428,31	12	-2
	Swift S-1 D-7125	6,54	7,79	7,25	8,50	0,00	7,21	7,51	6,72	8,89		1421,06
11	Marc DE BOUVIER DE CACHARD - FRA	4,5	6,0	6,0	7,5	6,0	8,5	8,0	7,5	8,0	0	Hi 1596,25	6	+5
	Swift S-1 HA-7022	4,93	6,60	6,59	7,67	5,84	8,20	7,91	7,05	8,05		1452,16
12	Jens HOHMANN - GER	6,0	6,5	6,0	7,5	5,0	6,5	6,0	5,0	6,5	0	1422,24	13	-1
	Swift S-1 D-5542	6,54	7,00	6,59	7,67	5,08	6,87	6,31	4,65	6,80		1430,25
13	Mirosław WRZEŚNIEWSKI - POL	6,5	8,0	7,0	8,5	6,5	8,0	8,0	6,5	8,5	1	1706,27	4	+9
	Swift S-1 SP-3532	7,08	8,19	7,25	8,50	6,22	7,87	7,91	CHZ	8,47		1479,38
14	Gisbert LEIMKÚHLER - GER	7,5	8,0	0,0	8,0	2,0	7,0	7,0	5,5	5,5	0	1249,00	14
	Swift S-1 D-3168	8,16	8,19	0,00	8,09	2,79	7,21	7,11	5,16	6,47		1255,57
		0	0	0	0	0	0	1	2	0	3	1		40

Figure Anomalies Summary

Distribution of Raw Marks - Judge vs. Panel

Judge O/all Proportion
Mark to CHZ	2	4
PZ to CHZ	-	-
AV to CHZ	-	-
AV to Mark	-	16
PZ to Mark	-	-
HZ to Mark	1	8
Lo to Mark	-	3
Hi to Mark	-	2
The 60% rule	-	-
Judge Anomalies vs. totals from all Judges

Review of Anomalies

Mark anomalies		Judge 1	Judge 2	Judge 3	Judge 4	Judge 5	Judge 6	Judge 7	Ch.Judge
Mirosław WRZEŚNIEWSKI - POL	Fig-8	HZ	6,5	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	CHZ
Swift S-1 SP-3532		HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ
Siegfried MAYR - AUT	Fig-7	HZ	7,5	HZ	HZ	8,5	7,5	HZ	CHZ
Swift S-1 OE-5554		HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ
Wolfgang SCHIECK - GER	Fig-8	AVGE	HZ	4,0	HZ	3,0	3,0	4,5	OK
Swift S-1 D-9590		4,36	4,36	4,17	4,36	4,78	4,11	4,38


Score anomalies	Judge 1	Judge 2	Judge 3	Judge 4	Judge 5	Judge 6	Judge 7
Marc DE BOUVIER DE CACHARD - FRA	1433,47	Hi 1596,25	1497,17	Lo 1377,13	1547,64	1394,27	1369,72
Swift S-1 HA-7022		1452,16		1466,24

Average and Spread of Marks

Review of RI Contributions per Pilot

Pilots not ranked correctly	Aeroplane	Judge FPS score	Bias Hi/Lo	Panel FPS score	Score difference	Judge FPS rank	Panel FPS rank	Rank diff'ce	RI value per pilot	Percent of total	RI contributions ranked by decreasing size
Mirosław WRZEŚNIEWSKI - POL	Swift S-1	1479,38	-	1430,60	48,78	4	13	+ 9	12,02	39,30%
Siegfried MAYR - AUT	Swift S-1	1559,93	-	1544,82	15,11	3	9	+ 6	5,08	16,60%
Charly LEVY LOUAPRE - FRA	Swift S-1	1614,01	-	1684,60	70,59	10	4	- 6	4,50	14,70%
Marc DE BOUVIER DE CACHARD - FRA	Swift S-1	1452,16	Hi	1458,52	6,36	6	11	+ 5	3,49	11,40%
Wolfgang SCHIECK - GER	Swift S-1	1598,76	-	1598,76	0,00	11	7	- 4	2,73	8,90%
Eric LENTZ-GAUTHIER - USA	Swift S-1	1617,53	-	1702,81	85,28	7	3	- 4	2,14	7,00%
Sebastian DIRLAM - GER	Swift S-1	1563,43	-	1599,30	35,87	8	6	- 2	0,42	1,40%
Bernhard BEHR - AUT	Swift S-1	1539,48	-	1562,84	23,36	9	8	- 1	0,11	0,40%
Robin KEMTER - GER	Swift S-1	1421,06	-	1460,12	39,06	12	10	- 2	0,03	0,10%
Jens HOHMANN - GER	Swift S-1	1430,25	-	1457,95	27,70	13	12	- 1	0,03	0,10%

									30,55

Pilots ranked correctly		Judge FPS score		Panel FPS score	Score difference	Judge FPS rank	Panel FPS rank
Maciej POSPIESZYŃSKI - POL	Swift S-1	1828,73		1768,42	60,31	1	1
Michael SPITZER - GER	Swift S-1	1780,59		1718,43	62,16	2	2
Michał KLIMASZEWSKI - POL	Swift S-1	1659,07		1661,70	2,63	5	5
Gisbert LEIMKÚHLER - GER	Swift S-1	1255,57		1350,10	94,53	14	14

Summary of RI Contributions per Nation

Judge:	Max nation bias = 12,02	Min = -3,20	Average = 4,41
Panel:	= 17,29	= -7,21	= 5,04

Calculations by: FairPlay v2 (non-scoring CJ + CHZ Summary)
Aerobatic Contest Results Organiser, ACRO Version 5.2 Build: 21/12/23