Judge: Remy LOUVEL

ACRO Sequence FPS Analysis for Judge 5: Remy LOUVEL - FRA

Ranking Index = 24,22

WGAC 2023, Toruń, Poland, July 26 to August 6

Pilot NAT = Judge NAT

FPS High value

FPS Low value

Unlimited - Glider, Programme 2: 1st Unknown Compulsory

HZ Anomalies

Set to Panel Avg

Raw and normalised / FPS revised Marks and Scores

FP Rank before penalties		Fig-1	Fig-2	Fig-3	Fig-4	Fig-5	Fig-6	Fig-7	Fig-8	Posi	No	Raw/FPS	J-rank	Diff
1	Maciej POSPIESZYŃSKI - POL	7,5	8,0	7,0	7,5	6,0	8,0	8,0	6,0	6,0	0	1688,92	3	-2
	Swift S-1 SP-3532	7,38	7,73	6,81	7,67	6,74	8,11	7,72	6,92	6,94		1696,72
2	Michael SPITZER - GER	8,0	8,0	7,0	7,5	6,5	7,5	6,5	HZ	7,0	1	1464,31	10	-8
	Swift S-1 D-3735	8,04	7,73	6,81	7,67	7,27	7,53	6,77	5,82	7,59		1680,72
3	Eric LENTZ-GAUTHIER - USA	8,0	8,0	8,5	8,0	5,0	7,0	8,0	4,0	7,5	0	1662,75	4	-1
	Swift S-1 HA-7022	8,04	7,73	7,98	8,09	5,67	6,94	7,72	5,49	7,92		1658,93
4	Charly LEVY LOUAPRE - FRA	7,0	8,5	8,0	8,0	6,5	7,0	8,5	6,0	8,5	0	1760,87	2	+2
	Swift S-1 HA-7022	6,72	8,21	7,59	8,09	7,27	6,94	8,04	6,92	8,57		1758,96
5	Michał KLIMASZEWSKI - POL	8,0	8,0	6,5	8,0	6,0	7,0	8,5	5,0	6,0	0	1657,79	5
	Swift S-1 SP-3532	8,04	7,73	6,42	8,09	6,74	6,94	8,04	6,21	6,94		1669,21
6	Sebastian DIRLAM - GER	6,5	7,0	7,0	7,0	6,0	7,5	8,0	4,0	5,5	0	1553,65	8	-2
	Swift S-1 D-7125	6,33	7,22	6,81	7,26	6,74	7,53	7,72	5,49	6,61		1579,19
7	Wolfgang SCHIECK - GER	6,5	8,0	8,5	8,5	4,0	7,5	8,5	3,0	7,5	0	1554,49	7
	Swift S-1 D-9590	6,06	7,73	7,98	8,50	4,61	7,53	8,04	4,78	7,92		1550,59
8	Bernhard BEHR - AUT	7,5	8,0	7,0	8,5	5,0	7,0	6,0	3,0	8,5	0	1563,60	6	+2
	Swift S-1 OE-5554	7,38	7,73	6,81	8,50	5,67	6,94	6,45	4,78	8,57		1568,57
9	Siegfried MAYR - AUT	8,5	9,0	8,5	8,5	7,0	8,0	8,5	6,0	8,5	1	Hi 1895,25	1	+8
	Swift S-1 OE-5554	8,70	8,69	7,98	8,50	7,80	8,11	CHZ	6,92	8,57		1545,38
10	Robin KEMTER - GER	7,0	8,0	6,5	8,5	0,0	8,5	7,5	6,5	8,5	0	1440,21	11	-1
	Swift S-1 D-7125	6,72	7,73	6,42	8,50	0,00	8,27	7,40	7,28	8,57		1438,83
11	Marc DE BOUVIER DE CACHARD - FRA	6,0	8,0	7,5	7,0	4,0	7,5	8,0	5,0	8,0	0	1545,82	9	+2
	Swift S-1 HA-7022	5,40	7,73	7,20	7,25	4,61	7,53	7,72	6,21	8,25		1529,61
12	Jens HOHMANN - GER	7,0	7,0	6,0	7,0	4,0	6,0	6,5	2,0	5,5	0	1345,52	13	-1
	Swift S-1 D-5542	6,72	6,76	6,04	7,25	4,61	5,78	6,77	4,06	6,61		1373,65
13	Mirosław WRZEŚNIEWSKI - POL	7,0	8,0	6,5	8,5	3,0	7,5	6,5	HZ	7,0	0	Lo 1261,11	14	-1
	Swift S-1 SP-3532	6,72	7,73	6,42	8,50	3,55	7,53	6,77	CHZ	7,59		1405,50
14	Gisbert LEIMKÚHLER - GER	8,5	9,0	0,0	8,5	4,0	8,0	6,0	5,0	5,5	0	1414,03	12	+2
	Swift S-1 D-3168	8,70	8,69	0,00	8,50	4,61	8,11	6,45	6,21	6,61		1416,46
		0	0	0	0	0	0	1	1	0	2	2		32

Figure Anomalies Summary

Distribution of Raw Marks - Judge vs. Panel

Judge O/all Proportion
Mark to CHZ	1	4
PZ to CHZ	-	-
AV to CHZ	-	-
AV to Mark	-	16
PZ to Mark	-	-
HZ to Mark	1	8
Lo to Mark	-	3
Hi to Mark	-	2
The 60% rule	-	-
Judge Anomalies vs. totals from all Judges

Review of Anomalies

Mark anomalies		Judge 1	Judge 2	Judge 3	Judge 4	Judge 5	Judge 6	Judge 7	Ch.Judge
Michael SPITZER - GER	Fig-8	6,5	6,5	5,5	7,0	HZ	5,0	6,0	OK
Swift S-1 D-3735		5,17	6,20	5,50	6,45	5,82	5,72	5,90
Siegfried MAYR - AUT	Fig-7	HZ	7,5	HZ	HZ	8,5	7,5	HZ	CHZ
Swift S-1 OE-5554		HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ	HZ


Score anomalies	Judge 1	Judge 2	Judge 3	Judge 4	Judge 5	Judge 6	Judge 7
Mirosław WRZEŚNIEWSKI - POL	1340,64	1482,76	1465,61	1500,93	Lo 1261,11	1359,28	1446,83
Swift S-1 SP-3532					1405,50
Siegfried MAYR - AUT	1431,88	1560,05	1492,57	1494,83	Hi 1895,25	1587,15	1612,78
Swift S-1 OE-5554					1545,38

Average and Spread of Marks

Review of RI Contributions per Pilot

Pilots not ranked correctly	Aeroplane	Judge FPS score	Bias Hi/Lo	Panel FPS score	Score difference	Judge FPS rank	Panel FPS rank	Rank diff'ce	RI value per pilot	Percent of total	RI contributions ranked by decreasing size
Siegfried MAYR - AUT	Swift S-1	1545,38	Hi	1544,82	0,56	1	9	+ 8	11,24	46,40%
Michael SPITZER - GER	Swift S-1	1680,72	-	1718,43	37,71	10	2	- 8	7,85	32,40%
Gisbert LEIMKÚHLER - GER	Swift S-1	1416,46	-	1350,10	66,36	12	14	+ 2	1,31	5,40%
Marc DE BOUVIER DE CACHARD - FRA	Swift S-1	1529,61	-	1458,52	71,09	9	11	+ 2	1,11	4,60%
Maciej POSPIESZYŃSKI - POL	Swift S-1	1696,72	-	1768,42	71,70	3	1	- 2	0,87	3,60%
Mirosław WRZEŚNIEWSKI - POL	Swift S-1	1405,50	Lo	1430,60	25,10	14	13	- 1	0,44	1,80%
Charly LEVY LOUAPRE - FRA	Swift S-1	1758,96	-	1684,60	74,36	2	4	+ 2	0,36	1,50%
Sebastian DIRLAM - GER	Swift S-1	1579,19	-	1599,30	20,11	8	6	- 2	0,30	1,20%
Jens HOHMANN - GER	Swift S-1	1373,65	-	1457,95	84,30	13	12	- 1	0,24	1,00%
Eric LENTZ-GAUTHIER - USA	Swift S-1	1658,93	-	1702,81	43,88	4	3	- 1	0,24	1,00%
Bernhard BEHR - AUT	Swift S-1	1568,57	-	1562,84	5,73	6	8	+ 2	0,13	0,50%
Robin KEMTER - GER	Swift S-1	1438,83	-	1460,12	21,29	11	10	- 1	0,12	0,50%

									24,22

Pilots ranked correctly		Judge FPS score		Panel FPS score	Score difference	Judge FPS rank	Panel FPS rank
Michał KLIMASZEWSKI - POL	Swift S-1	1669,21		1661,70	7,51	5	5
Wolfgang SCHIECK - GER	Swift S-1	1550,59		1598,76	48,17	7	7

Summary of RI Contributions per Nation

Judge:	Max nation bias = 11,37	Min = -7,21	Average = 2,08
Panel:	= 17,29	= -7,21	= 5,04

Calculations by: FairPlay v2 (non-scoring CJ + CHZ Summary)
Aerobatic Contest Results Organiser, ACRO Version 5.2 Build: 21/12/23